Every parent who throws a birthday party for their child will have to deal with the tyranny of party favors. Are they necessary? No, but kids love a goodie bag. The question I found myself asking was, what can I get that’s not a complete waste of money and won’t immediately go in the trash or drive adults up the wall? After throwing a combined six parties for two kids, the most recent one for my older son who just turned 5, I have a few ideas that don’t involve noisemakers, swirly straws (if I see another one of those again, I swear …), or junky plastic tchotchkes. I tried to stick to paper-based products as much as possible, or things that kids can actually use — and get excited about. Below, the best party favors for kids, as vetted by yours truly and several other Strategist parents.
Stickers are always a hit, and these waterproof ones that are inspired by Squishmallows are perfect for water bottles. Strategist senior editor Winnie Yang recently bought a bunch for her 8-year-old daughter, who likes to trade them with her classmates. This pack of 100 can easily be divided among goodie bags.
For my older son’s dinosaur-themed birthday party last year, I got this pack of puffy dinosaur stickers that actually look pretty decent.
A roll of sparkly stickers can also be fun. Cut off a few per kid, and you’re on your way.
For my son’s fifth birthday last month, I bought a variety of these four-by-six-inch Dover Little Activity Books that included sticker, stained-glass coloring, and puzzle books. Because I was hosting around 45 kids, I picked all the ones that were $2 and under. I also got sticker books with shells, Audubon birds, hummingbirds, woodland animals, and reptiles.
This rainforest-themed book comes with little scenes on the end covers on which to place stickers. And here’s an activity sticker book for train enthusiasts.
I also got a few of these coloring books that have designs printed on vellum paper that you can tear out and put on a window to catch the light.
Another time, I gave out these Field Notes–esque notebooks that were actually pretty close to the real thing.
Here’s a mixed-color pack that’s just as nice as the plain ones above.
Because I personally do not need anymore broken crayons lying around the house, I opted for these neon half-pencils last year to go with the notebooks. I was imagining kids drawing quietly in their notebooks or pretending they were detectives, jotting down clues.
This year, I got these fun, full-size pencils with cute animal erasers on them.
A friend with older kids told me she bought these hardcover sketchbooks for her daughter’s art-themed birthday party, where they would be creating their own books. The kraft cover is great for drawing on and decorating, too.
When my younger son turned 1 last year, I got a bunch of these mini tiger puzzles from Mudpuppy to go with the party’s tiger theme — the Chinese zodiac sign of the year he was born.
I love this idea from Strategist senior editor Jen Trolio, who gave out these break-your-own Moroccan geodes for one of her daughters’ birthdays last year. While they require the use of a hammer, they look pretty and are easy to break open, says Trolio. They were a smash hit (pun intended).
Trolio paired the geodes with (edible) jewels — a.k.a. Ring Pops.
Novelty candy, as long as you don’t give out too many so that other parents resent you for the impending sugar rush, is another fun favor that I usually include. I love these gummy burgers so much that I had a hard time holding myself back from eating them before finishing the gift bags.
A couple of Strategist parents have given out whoopee cushions as well for a tootin’ good time.
Here’s another silly activity book for older kids that Yang used as a stocking stuffer and says would work equally well in a goodie bag. “Perfect for potty-humored second-graders,” she says.
Rainbow scratch pads are another interactive favor with a lot of uses.
If it’s an outdoor party, sidewalk chalk could be another fun favor idea.
And finally, for a smaller party, check out these felt bananas that Strategist senior writer Liza Corsillo recently gave out at her son’s banana-themed 1-year-old birthday party. My kids were delighted to receive them — especially because the banana comes out of its peel.
The Strategist is designed to surface the most useful, expert recommendations for things to buy across the vast e-commerce landscape. Some of our latest conquests include the best acne treatments, rolling luggage, pillows for side sleepers, natural anxiety remedies, and bath towels. We update links when possible, but note that deals can expire and all prices are subject to change.
